Sleep Supplements: Do Those Pills and Powders Actually Help You Sleep Better?
Beyond the Hype, Let's See What Science Says
👋 Welcome to this edition of Sleepletter™ where we offer you easy-to-read insights from the latest research papers from the field of sleep neurobiology and clinical sleep medicine. Sign up to also receive Sleepletter by email.
🏆 Want to optimize your sleep or attend my "Ask Me Anything" session? Join us for exclusive seminars and events that unveil the science of sleep and receive personalized, actionable and science-backed recommendations how to improve sleep. Subscribe here!
If you've ever found yourself scrolling through health websites or standing in the supplement aisle wondering which sleep aid might actually help, you're not alone. With nearly 70 million Americans suffering from some type of sleep disorder and approximately 18% of adults regularly using sleep medications (both prescription and over-the-counter), the market for sleep supplements has exploded. But behind the marketing claims and celebrity endorsements, what does the science actually tell us?
Sleep supplements represent a significant segment of the wellness industry, with options ranging from herbal remedies to synthetic compounds. While many products promise better sleep, the scientific evidence supporting their efficacy varies dramatically. This article examines the current research on common sleep supplements to help you make informed decisions about what might actually help improve your sleep quality.
Melatonin: The Popular Choice
Melatonin is perhaps the most widely recognized sleep supplement, and for good reason - it's a hormone naturally produced by the pineal gland in your brain in response to darkness. This hormone plays a critical role in regulating your sleep-wake cycle, with levels gradually increasing in the evening to promote relaxation and prepare your body for sleep.
Melatonin supplements are synthetically produced in laboratory settings and have been extensively studied for their impact on sleep. Of seven randomized controlled trials identified in recent research, five demonstrated statistically significant improvements in sleep quality compared to placebo. However, it's worth noting that there's considerable inconsistency in the research regarding optimal dosing - some studies used 3 mg doses while others used 10 mg, and intervention lengths varied from 30 days to 6 months. Certain foods, such as tart cherries, pistachios, and walnuts, are naturally rich in melatonin and may help sleep, but the amounts required to reach doses used in studies (e.g. 1 mg of melatonin) are quite high and unlikely to be consumed through diet alone.
This inconsistency suggests that while melatonin shows promise, we still need more research to determine the ideal dosage and usage patterns for different populations. Additionally, melatonin is not recommended as a treatment for chronic insomnia and is often used for circadian rhythm disorders such as delayed sleep-wake phase disorder or jet lag, where its role is to help shift the timing of sleep rather than improve overall sleep quality or duration. That said, melatonin remains one of the better-supported supplements for sleep improvement.
Magnesium: Still Inconclusive
Magnesium has become increasingly popular as a sleep aid, which makes theoretical sense given its essential role in several sleep-related functions. Magnesium helps regulate gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), a neurotransmitter with calming effects on the nervous system. It also supports melatonin production, promotes muscle relaxation, and helps regulate stress responses.
Despite its popularity and theoretical benefits, clinical evidence for magnesium's effectiveness is surprisingly limited. In one randomized controlled trial, 100 healthy adults received either 320 mg of magnesium citrate or a placebo daily for seven weeks. Both groups reported improved sleep quality, with no significant difference between them. Interestingly, when researchers looked specifically at participants with low baseline magnesium levels, those receiving supplements did show significantly increased serum magnesium concentrations.
These findings suggest that magnesium supplementation may primarily benefit individuals with existing magnesium deficiencies rather than the general population. Foods rich in magnesium include nuts, seeds, legumes, whole grains, leafy greens, and fatty fish - incorporating these into your diet might be a more effective approach than supplements for most people.
Zinc: Limited Evidence
Zinc, an essential mineral found in foods like meat, seafood, legumes, and nuts, plays several roles that could theoretically impact sleep. It's involved in melatonin synthesis and regulation, influences neurotransmitter pathways related to GABA (promoting relaxation), and has anti-inflammatory properties that might indirectly support better sleep.
However, research specifically examining zinc supplementation for sleep is scarce. One study found marginal improvements in sleep quality among college-aged women with premenstrual syndrome who took 30 mg of elemental zinc daily for 12 weeks, though the results weren't statistically significant. Another study with intensive care unit nurses showed statistically significant improvements in sleep quality after one month of zinc sulfate supplementation (220 mg).
The existing evidence suggests potential benefits, but more research is certainly needed before making broad recommendations.
Vitamin D: Promising For Some
The relationship between vitamin D and sleep has gained attention as researchers have discovered vitamin D receptors in brain regions involved in sleep regulation. Additionally, vitamin D may influence serotonin synthesis, which plays a role in sleep-wake cycles.
In a notable study investigating vitamin D supplementation's impact on sleep, participants aged 20-50 with sleep disorders received either vitamin D3 (50,000 IU bi-weekly for eight weeks) or a placebo. The supplement group showed significant improvements in sleep quality, reduced sleep latency (time taken to fall asleep), and decreased sleep disturbances compared to the control group.
These improvements were attributed to vitamin D's potential role in regulating melatonin. Given the prevalence of vitamin D deficiency, particularly in northern climates and among people with limited sun exposure, vitamin D supplementation could be a simple and cost-effective strategy for improving sleep quality in those with low vitamin D levels.
L-Theanine: Calming Effects
L-theanine, an amino acid primarily found in green tea, has gained popularity for its potential calming effects. It readily crosses the blood-brain barrier and increases GABA production, potentially promoting relaxation and supporting the initiation of sleep.
In a randomized controlled trial, participants received either a placebo or 200 mg of L-theanine daily. The supplement group showed significant improvements in sleep quality compared to the control group. Additionally, participants experienced substantial decreases in stress-related symptoms and enhanced cognitive function.
While more research is needed to explore the direct relationship between L-theanine and sleep in diverse populations, initial findings are promising, particularly for those experiencing stress-related sleep issues.
Valerian Root: Mixed Evidence
Valerian root (Valeriana officinalis) is one of the most commonly used herbal agents for managing sleep disturbances, particularly for sleep-onset difficulties. Traditional use of valerian for sleep issues dates back to the 18th century in Europe, making it a well-established remedy with historical significance.
However, evidence on valerian's efficacy for insomnia is inconclusive. While valerian appears to have a good safety profile with minimal side effects, randomized controlled trials show mixed results for treating insomnia. A review found that valerian may improve subjective sleep quality in some individuals, but these effects haven't been consistently demonstrated with objective measurements.
Different studies used varying preparations and dosages (ranging from 6.4 mg to 3645 mg), which contributes to the heterogeneity in results. Some trials reported improvements in specific sleep parameters such as sleep latency (time to fall asleep), while others found no significant difference compared to placebo. The review notes that further high-quality randomized controlled trials are needed due to the scarcity of well-designed studies.
Ashwagandha: Promising Sleep Benefits
Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera), a traditional herb from Ayurvedic medicine, has been increasingly studied for its effects on sleep. A comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis examined the impact of Ashwagandha extract on sleep parameters in adults.
The analysis of five randomized controlled trials with 400 participants demonstrated that Ashwagandha extract has a small but significant beneficial effect on overall sleep quality compared to placebo. These improvements were more prominent in adults diagnosed with insomnia, with higher dosages (≥600 mg/day), and with treatment durations of 8 weeks or longer.
Ashwagandha also showed benefits for specific sleep parameters including sleep onset latency, total sleep time, wake time after sleep onset, and sleep efficiency. Additionally, the review found improvements in mental alertness upon waking and reduced anxiety levels among participants, which may indirectly contribute to better sleep.
Like valerian, Ashwagandha appears to have a favorable safety profile with only minor side effects reported in the studies reviewed. Ashwagandha extract may be considered as an option for improving sleep until more comprehensive evidence becomes available, particularly for those with insomnia seeking natural alternatives.
Nitrates: Emerging Area of Study
Nitrates, found in foods like beetroot and leafy greens, have been theorized to impact sleep through increased nitric oxide, which regulates blood flow and vascular function. However, research on nitrate supplementation for sleep quality is extremely limited.
One study examining the effects of beetroot juice (rich in nitrates) on male athletes found statistically significant improvements in sleep quality compared to placebo and control groups. However, another study found no impact on sleep quality when healthy men received a fruit and vegetable nitrate supplement.
The contradictory evidence suggests that nitrate supplementation's effects on sleep remain inconclusive, and more research is needed before recommendations can be made.
Finding What Works For You
Understanding that the science behind sleep supplements is still evolving means taking a thoughtful approach to their use. Before reaching for supplements, consider evidence-based approaches to improving sleep. Prioritizing sleep hygiene—maintaining consistent sleep schedules, creating a dark and cool bedroom environment, and limiting screen time before bed—remains the foundation of good sleep. If considering supplements, start by assessing potential nutritional gaps; for example, if you have limited sun exposure, vitamin D supplementation might be beneficial.
Different supplements may work better for different sleep issues. Melatonin may help with difficulty falling asleep, while magnesium might be more useful for those with restlessness or muscle tension. Particularly if you have existing health conditions or take medications, it's important to consult with healthcare providers before starting any supplement regimen.
The quest for better sleep is certainly worthwhile—quality sleep is essential for physical health, cognitive function, emotional wellbeing, and overall quality of life. While supplements may play a supportive role in addressing sleep challenges, they work best as part of a comprehensive approach to sleep health.
***
About the author
Alen Juginović is a medical doctor and postdoctoral researcher in the Department of Neurobiology at Harvard Medical School studying the effect of poor sleep quality on health. He is a member of the Editorial Board of the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, the official journal of the American Academy of Sleep Medicine. As a keynote speaker at conferences and teacher at Harvard College, he often discusses sleep's importance during the educational process and in media appearances. Alen is also focused on personalized sleep optimization for individuals and athletes (e.g. jet lag management), as well as being an advisor/investor/consultant for companies and individuals in the sleep field. He leads a team at Med&X Association organizing international award-winning conferences, including the Plexus Conference, which drew over 2,400 participants from 30+ countries, featuring 10 Nobel laureates and medical leaders. Med&X also collaborates with research labs and clinics from leading universities and hospitals around the world offering invaluable internships to help accelerate the development of top medical students, physicians and scientists. Feel free to contact Alen via LinkedIn for any inquiries.
Disclaimer: The content provided in this newsletter is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as medical or professional advice. The reader should consult with a medical professional for medical conditions or concerns, and with a financial or legal professional regarding any other specific needs or inquiries they may have related to the material discussed.
The writer expressly disclaims responsibility, obligation, or liability for actions taken by the reader in their unique circumstances based on any guidance, suggestions or recommendations made in this newsletter related to sleep health, optimization or hygiene. This content is not a substitute for personalized medical diagnosis, treatment or care from a trained physician.
The writer has made good faith efforts to confirm that all sleep science, research or health statistics referenced from third party sources are accurately represented. However, no warranty is made as to completeness or ongoing accuracy. Readers agree any reliance on newsletter content for decision making is at their sole discretion and risk. The writer is released of liability or claims related to applied use of this general educational content on sleep physiology or best practices.
Cartoon images generated with Adobe Firefly.